What usually counts as wear and tear
Generally wear and tear: Faded or slightly scuffed paint. Carpet worn along walking paths. Small nail holes from hanging pictures. Loose door handles or hinges. Minor scuffs on floors. Worn grout. Appliances failing from age.
Generally damage: Large or numerous holes in walls. Burns, pet stains or water damage in carpet. Broken windows, doors or fixtures. Missing appliances or fittings. Unapproved paint colours. Damage from neglecting to report a leak.
The underlying test in most states is whether the deterioration resulted from ordinary use over time, or from something a tenant did or failed to do.
Why the lease's own definition matters
Most leases use the phrase "normal wear and tear" and never define it. When it isn't defined, the practical effect is that the landlord's interpretation stands unless the tenant disputes it — and disputing it means small claims court.
Some leases go further and attempt to define specific items as tenant responsibility regardless of cause. Whether such a clause holds up depends on state law, and several states void lease terms that shift wear-and-tear costs onto tenants.
Depreciation: the concept that changes the maths
Even genuine damage usually can't be charged at full replacement cost. Many states apply a useful-life standard — carpet, for example, is often treated as having a life of five to ten years.
If carpet with a seven-year life is damaged in year six, a landlord is generally entitled to the remaining depreciated value, not the cost of a brand-new carpet. Deposit deductions that charge full replacement on old fittings are one of the most common overcharges.
The part most guides skip: photographs at move-IN, not move-outAlmost every guide advises photographing the property when you move out. The photographs that actually win disputes are the ones taken at move-in, because they establish the baseline condition — and without a baseline, "this stain was already here" is your word against theirs. Many states also require the landlord to provide a written move-in condition checklist, and where that exists, a signed copy is stronger evidence than any photo. If you're moving in soon, that checklist matters more than anything you can do on the way out.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Does the lease define normal wear and tear, or leave it open?
- Is there a move-in condition checklist, and did I receive a copy?
- Does the lease attempt to make me responsible for items regardless of cause?
- How many days does the landlord have to return the deposit?
- Is an itemised list of deductions required?
- Does the lease mention cleaning fees separately from damage?
Sources
- U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development — tenant rights resources by state
- IRS Publication 527 — useful life standards for residential rental property
This is general information, not legal advice. Docly helps you find and understand what a document actually says. It does not tell you whether a clause is enforceable where you live, and it is not a substitute for a lawyer. For a decision with real money attached, get advice from an attorney licensed in your state.
Find out what your contract actually says
Paste a clause or upload the whole document and ask in plain English. Every answer cites the exact line it came from.
Check a clause free →